Remembering Slavery and Freedom

The National Museum of African American History and Culture, December 2015 (Michael R. Barnes)
The National Museum of African American History and Culture, December 2015 (Michael R. Barnes)

What would a memorial to slavery look like? What story would it tell? What function would we want it to serve?

I thought about these questions this past weekend, attending parts of “The Future of the African American Past,” a state-of-the-field conference for black history organized by the NEH, the AHA, and the National Museum of African American History and Culture. Among the highlights of the conference for me was a panel on Slavery and Freedom, presented as a way to assess the enduring value of John Hope Franklin’s “slavery to freedom” paradigm as the organizing framework for African American history. In exploring that theme, panelists highlighted recent trends in this scholarship and started conversations about framing historical subjects as well as how people remember the past.

The panel examined the Civil-War-era process of emancipation and also slavery and freedom as distinct, intertwined experiences in the nineteenth century. Brenda Stevenson described the ways freedmen and women formalized marriages, analyzing the legal and emotional power that these rituals held for African Americans’ lives. Thavolia Glymph pushed against the prevailing tendency among historians to emphasize the shortfalls and problems of freedom. Glymph urged the audience to remember that while emancipation was not a simple end to black suffering, it did make a tremendous difference in the lives of freedpeople and in the nation’s legal and social structures.

I was particularly struck by the ideas running through presentations by Walter Johnson and Annette Gordon-Reed. Johnson pointed to the limits of our understandings of enslaved peoples’ internal lives, encouraging more work on the contours and varied possibilities of enslaved humanity. He also talked about the important, growing emphasis on slavery as part of the capitalist economy of the nineteenth-century Atlantic world. Annette Gordon-Reed offered thoughts on recent debates concerning memorialization and the public memory of the past. Her presentation tied the other scholars’ ideas to NMAAHC’s mission of bringing black history to the public. I was curious about how historians might bring together histories on vastly different scales—studying enslavement through individual lives and also through transnational economic systems—while also reshaping what people know about history through these approaches.

Together, the panelists offered a vision for how the museum might convey the complex history of slavery to visitors starting this Fall. Looking at slavery as a massive Atlantic economy does not necessarily mean ignoring the individuality of enslaved people; a key part of the humanity of enslaved individuals was their status as workers in an expansive capitalist economy. We can see that part of enslaved humanity in Solomon Northup’s narrative, a rich firsthand account of the work of the cotton industry, including the day-to-day labor that made cotton king and the brutality that planters imposed in an effort to keep that system running. We might also see this in the life of Moses Grandy, who worked for years navigating boats in the Chesapeake. Grandy arranged with his owner to earn money and purchase his freedom. Twice he purchased himself and twice his profit-seeking owners pocketed the agreed-upon sum and refused to allow Grandy his costly freedom. There are plenty of avenues to convey individual enslaved humanity and the centrality of the broader system of slavery to developments in massive Atlantic economies. The project for the museum is to marshal stories that help people see black enslavement and freedom as endlessly complex struggles and processes.



Share with a friend:
Copyright © AAIHS. May not be reprinted without permission.


Christopher Bonner

Christopher Bonner is an Assistant Professor of History at the University of Maryland, College Park. He specializes in African American history, particularly black protest in the early United States. He is at work on a manuscript titled “The Price of Citizenship,” which examines black activists’ efforts to construct American citizenship before the passage of the Fourteenth Amendment. Follow him on Twitter @63cjb.

Comments on “Remembering Slavery and Freedom

  • Avatar

    For intellectual historians, I can’t think of a more interesting slavery memorial than that which stands in Paris’s Jardin du Luxembourg. It pays tribute to enslaved people as among the architects of the *ideas* that undergird the French republic until today. It is difficult to imagine a U.S. official crediting enslaved people with being among the nation’s intellectual founders. I look forward to learning what the NMAAHC will have to say on this point.

    “Par leurs luttes et leur profond désir de dignité et de liberté, les esclaves des colonies françaises ont contribué à l’universalité des droits humains et à l’idéal de liberté, d’égalité et de fraternité qui fonde notre République. La France leur rend ici hommage.”

  • Avatar

    I would enjoy and learn more about African American history with a visit to the museum.

Comments are closed.